Sunday, July 17, 2011

Lattice 2011, Day Six

The last day of the conference had two last plenary sessions in the morning. The first began with a talk on lattice QCD with classical and quantum electrodynamics by Brian Tiburzi. In order to measure the electric polarisabilities of hadrons, their energy shift in a constant external electrical field is measured. Classical magnetic fields are also of interest, since they may affect the phase diagram of QCD by catalysing chiral symmetry breaking, possibly creating exotic superconducting phases of QCD matter. Quantum corrections to charged particle properties are also being studied using QED coupled to quarks, but this is still rather hard to do.

Next was John Bulava with a talk on excited hadrons. In order to study excited states, an approach like the GEVP is mandatory, which requires the measuring of multiple correlators with a suitable basis of operators. Since this basis eventually also needs to include multi-hadron states, some form of all-to-all propagators is neeeded, and John presented the distillation and the stochastic LapH approaches, which are based on an expansion in the low modes of the covariant Laplacian on a time slice.

After that, Dru Renner spoke about ETMC's recent work on QCD corrections to electroweak observables, in particular the (g-2) work for which they had been awared the Ken Wilson Award, but also new work on hadronic contributions to the running of αe.m. and new NLO results for (g-2), which however exclude the light-by-light contribution.

In the second plenary, Hartmut Wittig gave the review talk about low-energy particle physics and chiral extrapolations. The most recent results from the BMW collaboration on the light and strange quark masses are consistent with the FLAG averages, and this remains the case if BMW's lightest (physical and lighter) pion masses are omitted in the chiral extrapolation (or interpolation), indicating that pion masses below 250 MeV are light enough for few-percent accuracy in this area. There are, however, uncertainties in the overall scale of the pion and kaon decay constants which may be due to combined pion mass and discretisation effects. Hartmut also presented recent progress in the determination of gA of the nucleon.

A review of kaon physics was given by Robert Mawhinney. I'm afraid I can't adequately summarise his talk (there was just too much material).

The final talk was given by Anna Hasenfratz, who spoke about reweighting in the quark mass. Reweighting is an old idea, but recently it has picked up steam in lattice QCD and is now widely used to achieve lighter quark masses, to stabilise simulations, or to incorporate electromagnetic effects. Since the overlap between the simulated and the target distribution must not be too small, the Hasenbusch trick has to be used when reweighting to small quark masses. A new, quadrature-based, approach avoiding the need for inversions has been introduced at this conference by Abdel-Rehim et al.

After this, the conference closed with a round of well-deserved applause for the Local Organising Committee.

Lattice 2011, Day Five

Sorry for the delayed update; I was too tired to blog last night.

The first plenary of the fifth day started with a talk by David Kaplan with the intriguing title "Listening to Noise". The topic of the talk was in fact noise, which of course affects baryonic correlators particularly badly. Studying unitary fermions as a toy model, David Kaplan showed that the distribution of the measured correlator values approaches a log-normal distribution, i.e. their logarithms approach a normal distribution. Exploiting this, one can attempt to use the cumulants of the measured distribution to extract an effective mass with reduced noise, and this does indeed work in the case of unitary fermions. For QCD, additional tricks may be needed.

The next talk was given by Kostas Orginos, who gave a review of hadron interactions on the lattice. This is still a very difficult problem, and new and better methods will be needed to make progress.

The last talk before the break was on a non-scientific topic, namely the situation in Japan after the great earthquake, presented by Shojo Hashimoto. Besides the terrible loss of life and the large number of people made homeless by the tsunami, the subsequent nuclear meltdown at Fukushima has further worsened the impact of the disaster. Not only have numerous towns been contaminated by Cs-137 (it takes a real physicist to show a curve of the measured radiation and remark upon the perfect exponential curve described by the decay of I-131), but also the power supply has been adversely affected by the shutdown of the nuclear power plants; a shortfall of 10-15% is expected in the summer, and hence power-intensive scientific facilities such as PACS-CS can only run at night. The US and the UK have stepped into the gap and have donated computer time on their machines to Japanes colleagues.

The second plenary was devoted to flavour physics. Enrico Lunghi spoke about the tensions observed in the unitarity triangle fits between sin(2β) and the branching ratio B --> τν, in (g-2)μ, φBs, and the branching ratio Bs --> μ+μ-. The LHCb experiment should be able to clarify the situation soon.

This was followed by a review of heavy-flavour physics on the lattice by Christine Davies, who summarised the different approaches (NRQCD, HQET, Fermilab, relativistic heavy quarks on fine lattices with highly improved actions) and results for the charm and bottom masses and the decay constants and form factors of charm and bottom mesons, as well as for the B meson mixing parameters.

The plenary session closed with the invitation to LATTICE 2012 to be held in Cairns, Australia, from 24th to 29th June 2012.

In the afternoon there were parallel sessions one last time (this included my own talk in the last possible slot).

Friday, July 15, 2011

Lattice 2011, Days Three and Four

Wednesday was the customary short day, without any plenaries and with morning parallel sessions. The afternoon was free for excursions. I joined some colleagues on a self-organised hiking trip on the Five Lakes Route, which was a short drive from the Village. The view from the upper parts of the trail was very nice, and the hike not too strenuous. At the end, the path got kind of lost in snow, so we only saw one of the five lakes before descending again.

Today's plenaries were almost entirely devoted to finite-temperature QCD. The first speaker of the first session was Ludmilla Levkova, who gave the review talk on finite temperature and density. Since it is always hard to summarise a summary, I'll refrain from tyring, and instead just highlight some of the things in her talk that I found particularly interesting. One is that there are efforts to understand the effects of magnetic fields on the nature of the QCD phase transition; this never occurred to me as a question, but once you realise that the magnetic fields in off-axis heavy-ion collisions are of the order of 1014 T, it seems quite a natural problem. The other was that the equation of state obtained from different lattice actions comes out significantly different. Some hope to resolve those differences may come from a new method to determine the equation of state that has recently been introduced by Giusti and Meyer.

The next talk was another experimental talk, given by Barbara Jacak of the PHENIX experiment. It is now known that the quark-gluon plasma is a nearly perfect liquid, and there is evidence that all strongly coupled plasmas are alike in some sense. Important remaining questions on which input from the lattice is needed are whether there are quasiparticles in the QGP and if so, what they are, as well as whether there are any relevant screening lengths.

The second plenary was opened with Swagato Mukherjee speaking about fluctuations and correlations at finite chemical potential. Since the fermionic determinant is in general no longer real in the presence of a chemical potential, no direct Monte Carlo evaluation of the path integral is possible in this case. A way around this is to consider the Taylor-expansion around zero chemical potential, and in this case generalised susceptibilities arise as Taylor coefficients. These can be related to moments of fluctuations of the baryon number, which are accessible experimentally. In order to connect the experiments, which controlled by the center of mass energy \sqrt{s}, to theoretical determinations which are controlled by the temperature T and the chemical potential μ, the hadron gas model is used, apparently with good success.

Next was a talk about U(1)A in hot QCD by Prasad Hegde. At zero temperature, the axial U(1) symmetry of QCD is broken by the axial anomaly, which among other things gives rise to the η/η' mass splitting. Since the spontaneously broken chiral SU(Nf)LxSU(Nf)R symmetry is restored at finite temperature, it may be natural to ask if the same happens for the axial U(1) symmetry. Indeed, since the axial anomaly is related to the topological charge of the fields, it is known that the axial U(1) symmetry is restored in the infinite-temperature limit by the screening of the chromoelectric fields (as the topological charge density is proportional to E.B). However, studies using both staggered and domain wall quarks indicate clearly that U(1)A remains broken above the critical temperature.

The last talk of the morning was by Balint Jóo, who gave a review of the role of GPUs in lattice simulations. By now, many lattice groups have discovered GPUs as a cost-effective means of accelerating computations, which however have their own issues (in particular related to the programming model and to the PCIe bus as a bottleneck in transferring data between GPUs and the CPU). A number of QCD codes have been or are being ported to GPUs (QUDA, QDP++ for GPUs).

In the afternoon there were parallel sessions again. In the evening, we took the cable car to High Camp, which is located at an altitude of about 8100 ft (ca. 2500 m) for the conference banquet. The buffet was good, the desserts very rich, the wine rather effective due to the reduced oxygen pressure at high altitude (for which reason I ask to be forgiven for any mistakes in this summary), and the view from the cable car truly spectacular.

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Lattice 2011, Day Two

Hello again from Squaw Valley.

Today's first plenary was devoted entirely to beyond-the-Standard-Model physics. The first speaker was Aleksi Kurkela, who spoke about large extra dimensions and the lattice. Extra dimensions are phenomenologically appealing, but since gauge theories in d>4 are non-renormalisable, they are defined only up to a regularisation. Results from the ε-expansion suggest the existence of a non-Gaussian UV fixed point in higher dimensions, but since d=5 is well outside of the expected convergence radius of the expansion, lattice studies are needed to check this; for the isotropic case it does not appear to be true, but for the anisotropic case there is evidence that it is indeed true. When the fifth dimension is compactified, new effects arise; in some cases, knowledge of the correlation length of the dimensionally reduced theory can give bounds on the compactification radius.

The second plenary talk was the traditional experimental talk, delivered by Adam Martin from Fermilab. With 1 fb-1 of data both ATLAS and CMS can exclude the Higgs mass range from 130 GeV to 460 GeV at the 95% confidence level; with 5-10 fb-1, they should be able to either exclude the full mass range up to 600 GeV or else claim a 5σ discovery. In the low mass range, the Tevatron is currently still more sensitive; CDF has seen a bump in the W/Z+jj cross section, which appears to be ruled ou by D0, so this seems to be a case where backgrounds need to be understood better before reaching any conclusions. Other interesting discrepancies include the tt forward-backward asymmetry and the like-sign dimuon charge asymmetry. We should "stay tuned this summer for exciting results".

The BSM theme was continued in the second plenary. Ethan Neil gave a talk about new physics models on the lattice, giving an account of the (Nc, Nf, representation) space of models studied in the search for the conformal window, and of the methods used to study them, including spectral studies, studies of finite-T phase transitions and the Monte Carlo Renormalisation Group.

In the next talk, Daniel Nogradi spoke about a specific model that has particular phenomenological appeal, namely the SU(3) theory with Nf=2 fermions in the sextet representation. This theory has exactly three Goldstone bosons, allowing for Higgs-less electroweak symmetry breaking, and may allow for a small S-parameter (unacceptably large values for the S-parameter being a problem plaguing many technicolor-like models).

At the end of the plenary sessions, the first Ken Wilson lattice award was awarded to Xu Feng, Karl Janssen, Marcus Petschlies and Dru Renner for their recent paper on the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon.

In the afternoon, there were parallel sessions, and in the evening, the poster session took place.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Lattice 2011, Day One

Hello from The Village at Squaw Valley, where I am at the Lattice 2011 conference.
Having arrived late yesterday (actually early today), I still feel rather tired and would like to ask my readers to ascribe any glaring errors or omissions in todays post to that fact.

The welcome was in a different style from the usual speeches -- we were shown a short movie by Massimo Di Pierro that combined elements of "Star Wars" and the "Powers of 10" educational film with images of topological charge densities measured on the lattice. Also unusual was the announcement of a Tesla card raffle sponsored by nVidia.

After that, the first plenary session started with a talk by Eigo Shintani on the determination of αs from lattice QCD. In fact, currently lattice determinations are dominating the world average for αs(MZ2), although there are some discrepancies with other methods. Shintani focussed mainly on the efforts of the JLQCD collaboration, which is based on measuring the light quark vacuum polarisation using dynamical overlap fermions, which then can be compared directly to an operator product expansion performed in the continuum, and αs can be determined by matching to continuum perturbation theory. Other determinations that have been performed have used the Schrödinger functional (ALPHA, PAC-CS), Wilson loops and lattice perturbation theory (HPQCD), and moments of heavy quark current-current correlators (also HPQCD).

The next speaker was Shou-Cheng Zhang from Stanford, who spoke about a topic condensed matter theory that has some interesting connections to lattice QCD, namely topological insulators and superconductors. These are "materials that realise theoretical ideas" in that they cause concepts that are otherwise the realm of theory to appear in an experimentally accessible context. Examples included the appearance of the 3-dimensional Wilson-Dirac operator in the description of a two-dimensional topological insulator, the possibility to have a QED θ-term with θ=π in a topological superconductor, or the appearance of a Dirac monopole as the image charge of a point charge in front of a topological superconductor. These materials also have the possibility to have an enormous technological impact by creating the possibility of having dissipation-free electron flows at room temperature, which could revolutionised electronics and lead to much faster computers.

The last speaker of the session was Mithat Ünsal talking on large-N volume independence and related ideas. Provided that translation invariance and centre symmetry are not spontaneously broken, there is the possibility of reducing QCD in the limit of infinitely many colours to a large-N matrix model. While the Eguchi-Kawai model and its various extensions have failed due to centre symmetry breaking, there appears to be some hope that some other kinds of matrix models could give new insights into gauge theories.

After the coffee break, the second plenary of the day began with Laurence Yaffe speaking about an approach to heavy-ion collisions that begins with simplifying the complicated situation to the much simpler of colliding shockwaves in N=4 super-Yang-Mills theory, which has a dual description as a collision of gravitational waves via the AdS/CFT correspondence. After thus reducing a non-equilibrium problem in a strongly coupled QFT with an initial-value problem in a classical field theory, it turns out that after applying a number of tricks, Einstein's equations for this situation can be converted into a set of nested ODEs that can be solved numerically.

Next was a talk by Jack Laiho on Asymptotic Safety and Quantum Gravity. The concept of asymptotic safety as introduced by Weinberg states that a perturbatively non-renormalisable theory may still be well-defined and possess predictive power if its renormalisation group flow has an ultraviolet fixed point with a finite number of relevant directions. There is some numerical evidence that gravity might be asymptotically safe with only three parameters. In a Euclidean framework, asymptotic safety corresponds to the existence of a critical point. This scenario has been studied in a number of different formulations, including the Euclidean dynamical triangulations of Ambjorn et al. (which have a crumpled phase with infinite Hausdorff dimension and a branched polymer phase with Hausdorff dimension 2, separated by a first-order phase transition, and hence no hope to describe continuum physics) and the Causal Dynamical Triangulations of Ambjorn and Loll (which have a large-scale solution in the form of de Sitter space, and where the spectral dimension runs from 2 at short scales to 4 at large scales). Jack and his student have studied what happens if one adds a measure term to the Regge action, and have found that there are three phases (collapsed, extended, and branched polymer phase) with the possibility of a critical end point in the phase diagram, which could realise the scenario of asymptotic safety. There is also evidence that the spectral dimensions runs from 4 at large scales to 3/2 at short scales, where the dimension 3/2 would reconcile the requirements of holography and the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.

The last plenary speaker of the day was Paul Rakow, who spoke about flavour-blindness and the pattern of flavour breaking in Nf=3. Since the masses of the light and strange quarks are not identical, the SU(3) flavour symmetry is explicitly broken. Expanding in this breaking around the symmetric theory and exploiting the representation theory of SU(3) allows one to understand the way the physical point is approached in lattice simulations.

In the afternoon there were parallel sessions.